|
From
•>>June 2006
- [late entry]
Dik Heg
answer a
few questions about this month's emerging
research front in
the field of Plant & Animal Science. The
author has also
sent along images of their work.
Plant & Animal Science
Article: Predation risk is an ecological constraint for helper dispersal in a cooperatively breeding cichlid
Authors: Heg,
D;Bachar, Z;Brouwer, L;Taborsky, M
Journal: PROC ROY SOC LONDON SER B, 271 (1555): 2367-2374 NOV 22 2004
Addresses:
Univ Bern, Dept Behav Ecol, Inst Zool, Wohlenstr 50A, CH-3032 Hinterkappelen, Switzerland.
Univ Bern, Dept Behav Ecol, Inst Zool, CH-3032 Hinterkappelen, Switzerland.
Univ Groningen, Anim Ecol Grp, Ctr Ecol & Evolutionary Studies, NL-9750 AA Haren, Netherlands.
|
|

Why do you think your paper is
highly cited?
We have been the first to conduct an experimental study on
an issue which has been around in the literature on
cooperatively breeding animals for many years: Might predation
risk explain why subordinate individuals ("helpers")
delay dispersal and instead remain at home and assist the
dominant group members raising offspring (so called
"ecological constraints hypothesis")?
We have shown that experimentally altered predation risk
increases the likelihood of helpers staying in their natal
territory, and show that helpers benefit from staying because
of increased survival, particularly in larger groups.
Does it describe a new discovery, methodology, or
synthesis of knowledge?
The number of experimental studies addressing the effects
of ecological constraints on the propensity of helpers to
disperse is very limited and ours is the first to
experimentally test the effects of predation risk. I hope that
due to our publications, scientists will realize how
excellently the cooperatively breeding cichlids of Lake
Tanganyika are for experimental studies, addressing for
instance basic questions in behavioral, ecological , and
evolutionary science, both in the field and in the laboratory.
Could you summarize the significance of your paper in
layman's terms?
The Great East African Lakes (Lake Tanganyika, Victoria,
and Malawi) all contain unique endemic cichlid fish species
schools and have been hotspots of biological research during
the past decades. Lake Tanganyika stands out as having about
20 species of Lamprologine cichlids showing cooperative
breeding.
In these species, subordinate, smaller group members assist
a dominant breeding pair in raising offspring by engaging in,
for instance, territory defense and brood care. This is an
exceedingly rare phenomenon in fish, but occurs often in
insects, mammals, and birds.
We have been conducting many experimental studies on the
social systems of these cichlids. In this particular study, we
erected large 2x2x2 meter underwater cages, encompassing the
territories of two to three breeding groups of the cichlid Neolamprologus
pulcher (dominants with subordinates).
In some cages, all predators were removed, and, in others,
one medium or one large predator was added. These predators
pose a severe threat to these cichlids and can catch and kill
the subordinates. We show that subordinates rather stay in the
natal group when predators were around and hide in the
shelters provided by the group.
However, subordinates readily disperse and breed by
themselves when predators were removed—supporting the so
called "ecological constraints hypothesis." This
shows that subordinates take account of the risk of leaving
the natal territory, and this may explain why subordinates
usually stay at home rather than disperse under natural
circumstances when many predatory fish are around.
How did you become involved in this research, and were
any problems encountered along the way?
I have been conducting studies on the social behavior of
birds and beetles before I joined the group of Professor
Michael Taborsky in 2001. This meant a change from being a
terrestrial biologist to an aquatic biologist, although my
major research interest remained the same—ecological and
evolutionary questions concerning behavior.
Doing ecological research while SCUBA diving is like
training for a space shuttle flight for three years, three
months-per-year, two dives-per-day of two to three hours each!
It is interesting to see how things which are simple on land
start to get pretty complicated, when you are 10 meters down,
under water, and breathing through a regulator.
Using underwater cages of this size was not easy, but due
to the excellent design by Rolf Eggler and the help of people
from the Lake Tanganyika Diving Expeditions 2002 & 2003,
the Tanganyika Lodge, and the Fisheries Department in Mpulungu,
we were able to do this study.
Are there any social or political implications for your
research?
I hope our research helps to protect the Lake Tanganyika
cichlids for future generations, by increasing people’s
awareness of this splendid Lake (see also "The Cichlid
Fishes: Nature’s Grand. Experiment in Evolution" by
George W. Barlow, Perseus Publishing, Cambridge, MA,
2000).
Luckily, no major ecological catastrophes have been
detected (yet) in Lake Tanganyika, in contrast to Lake
Victoria where the introduction of the Nile perch has
exterminated many endemic cichlid species—see the excellent
popular book Darwin’s Dreampond by Tijs Goldschmidt, MIT
Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1998.
I hope our research will support the continued funding of
the Fisheries Department in Mpulungu (Dr. Harris Phiri and his
co-workers, Ministry of Agriculture and Co-operatives of
Zambia) to continue their monitoring of the hydrological,
limnological, and ecological state of the Lake, to detect
changes and take action when needed, and also as soon as
necessary.
Dr. Dik Heg
Department of Behavioural Ecology
Zoological Institute
University of Bern
Hinterkappelen, Switzerland
|
|
A Closer Look...
|
 |
Below
are images sent in by Dik Heg which correspond with the featured
paper, or current research. |
|
|
Figure 1:

|
|
Figure
1: A breeding group of the cichlid Neolamprologus brichardi/pulcher defending their territory against the predatory fish Lepidiolamprologus elongatus (left). The smaller group members rather stay at home and assist the breeder raising offspring than disperse and breeding independently, when exposed to such predation risk. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Figure 2:

|
|
Figure
2: Fig2: Experimental studies of these cichlids are conducted using SCUBA diving in Lake Tanganyika at 2 to 15 meter depth. Basic information on the social systems of the endemic Lake Tanganyika cichlids are obtained by catching individual fish, measuring and marking them and bv taking small DNA samples (small fin clip) for genetic analyses. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Figure 3:

|
|
Figure
3: The pristine Tanganyika Lodge on the shoreline of Lake Tanganyika at Kasakalawe village near Mpulungu (Zambia). This is the home base for the field studies by the Department of Behavioural Ecology, University of Bern, Switzerland. In the background one can see how underwater cages are erected for experimental ecological studies. These cages are then transported by boat to the exact location where they will be dropped into the water. |
|
| |
|
Return to Emerging Research Fronts | Return
to Special Topics main menu
|