Beginning in mid-February 2008, the 1997-2007 online version of the Science Watch® newsletter, ESI-Topics.com, and in-cites.com, will all be featured together on the redesigned ScienceWatch.com. All previous content from the three sites will be permanently archived, and remain accessible from any existing bookmarks to the archived pages. No new content will be added to this site. Updates and new content (updated biweekly) are available at ScienceWatch.com now.

Fast Breaking Comments

By Philip Marriott & Robert Shellie

ESI Special Topics, April 2004
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/fbp/2004/april04-Shellie_Marriott.html

Philip Marriott & Robert Shellie answer a few questions about this month's fast breaking paper in the field of Engineering.


From •>>April 2004

Field: Engineering
Article Title: Principles and applications of comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography
Authors: Marriott, P;Shellie, R
Journal: TRAC-TREND ANAL CHEM
Volume: 21
Page: 573-583
Year: SEP-OCT 2002
* RMIT Univ, Australian Ctr Res Separat Sci, Dept Appl Chem, GPO Box 2476V, Melbourne, Vic 3001, Australia.
* RMIT Univ, Australian Ctr Res Separat Sci, Dept Appl Chem, Melbourne, Vic 3001, Australia.

ST:  Why do you think your paper is highly cited?

Philip Marriott
Robert Shellie
The paper describes the basic technology for GCxGC, and how results for the 2D method are generated”

Comprehensive 2D GC (GCxGC) is a relatively new technique, but has made significant impact in the area of high-resolution GC analysis. There has been a rapidly growing interest in the opportunities afforded by GCxGC. The core group of research groups who have been working in this area over the past five years has now been expanded by many other groups who recognize the need for improved analysis of complex volatile samples. Because of these factors, reviews such as ours will attract citations because they place the technique into context and provide a useful background to the technique. Our research group's reasonably strong contribution to the original literature in this area probably explains why our publications attract some attention, and this may add to the citation impact.

ST:  Does it describe a new discovery or a new methodology that's useful to others?

The paper describes the basic technology for GCxGC, and how results for the 2D method are generated. Because it is a review rather than original research, it presents the new technology in context, and describes how it has been applied to a range of selected applications areas, giving a reasonably comprehensive account of the key areas to which it has been applied.

ST:  Could you summarize the significance of your paper in layman's terms?

Perhaps the significance of this review is not so much anything that is revealed in the review, but the inherent value offered by an improved analysis that is the justification for the review—in this case aided by improved resolution—to the study of complex volatile samples. After many years of trying to push single column GC (and GC/MS) to the limits for characterization of mixtures—a limit that essentially has been reached—this new approach has the potential to solve separation problems and sample characterization in ways previously not thought possible. The review was probably the right review at the right time to attract the attention of researchers in this area.

ST:  How did you become involved in this research?

We developed a cryogenic modulation system that operates by using a longitudinally moving cryotrap (in the mid-1990s), which was able to trap and very rapidly remobilize GC peaks as they traveled along a capillary GC column. We originally intended this to be used as a way to handle multidimensional heartcut zones in GC, but very soon realized that it would have great utility as a modulation method in the GCxGC technique, and so we pioneered the use of cryogenic methods in this area. Our group has published about 35% of the research papers that have appeared on GCxGC, studying both fundamental principles and applications. We are now developing a range of other technologies that use GCxGC approaches but in more of a traditional multidimensional manner, combined with fast MS methods. It has been a fascinating journey to be able to explore new methods very early in their development, and seeing them become accepted within the general GC community.End

Philip Marriott 
Professor of Separation Science
School of Applied Sciences (Applied Chemistry)
RMIT University
Melbourne, Australia

Robert Shellie
PhD student
School of Applied Sciences (Applied Chemistry)
RMIT University
Melbourne, Australia

ESI Special Topics, April 2004
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/fbp/2004/april04-Shellie_Marriott.html

•> Search Special Topics
Fast Breaking Papers Menu || All Topics Menu
Fast Breaking Papers Comments Menu
Help || About || Contact

ScienceWatch.com - Tracking Trends and Perfomance in Basic Research
Go to the new ScienceWatch.com

Write to the Webmaster with questions/comments. Terms of Usage.
The Research Services Group of Thomson Scientific |
(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.