Beginning in mid-February 2008, the 1997-2007 online version of the Science Watch® newsletter, ESI-Topics.com, and in-cites.com, will all be featured together on the redesigned ScienceWatch.com. All previous content from the three sites will be permanently archived, and remain accessible from any existing bookmarks to the archived pages. No new content will be added to this site. Updates and new content (updated biweekly) are available at ScienceWatch.com now.

New Hot Paper Comments

By Raoul Herbrecht

ESI Special Topics, January 2004
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/nhp/2004/january-04-RaoulHerbrecht.html

Raoul Herbrecht answers a few questions about this month's new hot paper in the field of Clinical Medicine.


From •>>January 2004

Field: Clinical Medicine
Article Title: Voriconazole versus amphotericin B for primary therapy of invasive aspergillosis
Authors: Herbrecht, R;Denning, DW;Patterson, TF;Bennett, JE;Greene, RE;Oestmann, JW;Kern, WV;Marr, KA;Ribaud, P;Lortholary, O;Sylvester, R;Rubin, RH;Wingard, JR;Stark, P;Durand, C;Caillot, D;Thiel, E;Chandrasekar, PH;Hodges, MR;Schlamm, HT;Troke, PF;de Pauw, B
Journal: N ENGL J MED
Volume: 347
Page: 408-415
Year: AUG 8 2002
* Hop Hautepierre, Dept Hematol & Oncol, Ave Moliere, F-67098 Strasbourg, France.
* Hop Hautepierre, Dept Hematol & Oncol, F-67098 Strasbourg, France.
* Univ Manchester, Manchester, Lancs, England.
* Univ Texas, Hlth Sci Ctr, San Antonio, TX USA.
* NIAID, Bethesda, MD 20892 USA.
* Massachusetts Gen Hosp, Boston, MA 02114 USA.
* Campus Virchow Klinikum, Charite, Berlin, Germany.
* Univ Freiberg, Med Klin, Freiburg, Germany.
* Fred Hutchinson Canc Res Ctr, Seattle, WA 98104 USA.
* Inst Pasteur, Paris, France.
* European Org Res Treatment Canc, Brussels, Belgium.
* Brigham & Womens Hosp, Boston, MA 02115 USA.
* Univ Florida, Coll Med, Gainesville, FL USA.
* Univ Calif San Diego, San Diego, CA 92103 USA.
* Hop Bocage, Dijon, France.
* Univ Hosp Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany.
* Wayne State Univ, Sch Med, Detroit, MI USA.
* Pfizer, Global Res & Dev, New York, NY USA.
* Pfizer, Global Res & Dev, Sandwich, Kent, England.
* Univ Nijmegen, Med Ctr, Nijmegen, Netherlands.
* Hop St Louis, Paris, France.

ST:  Why do you think your paper is highly cited?

Invasive mycoses are a key concern for clinicians in charge of severely immunosuppressed patients. The incidence of these infections—especially of invasive aspergillosis—is steadily increasing, and aspergillosis has become one of the leading causes of death in hematology and hematopoietic stem cell transplantation departments. Recently, new diagnostic tools, such as galactomannan antigen detection in serum or in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, have been shown to allow earlier diagnosis of invasive aspergillosis. In addition, several new antifungal agents have been licensed recently or are under investigation. In this very fast-moving field, our study has created a new standard for both the methodology of clinical trials in invasive aspergillosis and for the treatment of this disease.

ST:  Does it describe a new discovery or a new methodology that's useful to others?


We demonstrated in our study that a new antifungal agent, voriconazole, was clearly more effective than amphotericin B.

For nearly 40 years, amphotericin B has been the standard treatment for invasive aspergillosis. We demonstrated in our study that a new antifungal agent, voriconazole, was clearly more effective than amphotericin B. The superiority of voriconazole over amphotericin B was evident in a higher proportion of patients responding to therapy, and, most importantly, in a far better survival rate. Our study is the first published comparative clinical trial in the field of invasive fungal infections to demonstrate a statistically significant difference in patient survival between treatment arms. Following this trial, voriconazole has become the new standard therapy for invasive aspergillosis, regardless of the site of infection or the patient’s underlying condition. Hematologists, infectious disease specialists, and intensive care physicians have accepted voriconazole as the new standard for invasive aspergillosis. We also showed that it is possible to perform a large randomized study in invasive aspergillosis (this trial is actually the largest ever done, with 391 patients recruited). Our success results from the joint efforts of two groups, the Invasive Fungal Infection Group (IFIG) of the European Organisation for the Research and Treatment of Cancer, and the Global Aspergillus Study Group, driven by North American experts. In total, 95 investigators from 19 countries were involved in the study. All case report forms were reviewed by an independent data review committee where the presence of four expert radiologists was invaluable in assessing both disease at baseline and the response to therapy. In addition, the information collected during the radiological assessments were included in a database, and now offer a unique opportunity to describe the radiological findings of invasive aspergillosis more accurately than has been possible previously. One or more further publications are expected.

ST:  Could you summarize the significance of your paper in layman's terms?

Invasive aspergillosis is a devastating infectious disease caused by the mold Aspergillus. Such infections are most common in the lungs, but can affect virtually all parts of the body. In a large review article from 2001, approximately 60% of patients with invasive aspergillosis died, although in some groups of patients—such as those receiving bone marrow transplants—this figure was greater than 90%. There are relatively few drugs available to treat fungal infections, and before this study was conducted, the most commonly used treatment for invasive aspergillosis was amphotericin B. Although it was widely used, amphotericin B was far from ideal, because of its limited efficacy and poor tolerability. Many patients cannot be treated with amphotericin B for long periods, due to the side effects associated with this drug. Ours is the largest study of invasive aspergillosis ever published, and clearly shows that more patients treated with voriconazole survived until the end of the study than those treated with amphotericin B. In addition to improving the chance of survival, voriconazole also cured or improved the Aspergillus infection in more than half of the patients who received this drug. In contrast, less than a third of the patients treated with amphotericin B had similar responses. As a result of this study, voriconazole is now widely regarded as the new standard therapy for patients with invasive Aspergillus infections.

ST:  How did you become involved in this research?

For many years, I have been involved in clinical trials assessing new diagnostic or therapeutic strategies for infections—especially fungal infections—in immunosuppressed patients. Prior to this study, we had demonstrated that Strasbourg University Hospital had one of the largest accrual capabilities in Europe for this type of trial. Dr. David Denning (Manchester, UK), who first proposed and worked on this project at the IFIG, asked me to join him to help coordinate the European part of this study. Subsequently, I was elected chairman of the IFIG and, as chairman of this group, I am proud to see that we have established a friendly and fruitful trans-Atlantic collaboration, which we expect to continue for new projects.End

Raoul Herbrecht
Département d'Hématologie et d'Oncologie
Hôpital de Hautepierre
Strasbourg, France

ESI Special Topics, January 2004
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/nhp/2004/january-04-RaoulHerbrecht.html

•> Search Special Topics
New Hot Papers Menu || All Topics Menu
New Hot Papers Comments Menu
Help || About || Contact

ScienceWatch.com - Tracking Trends and Perfomance in Basic Research
Go to the new ScienceWatch.com

Write to the Webmaster with questions/comments. Terms of Usage.
The Research Services Group of Thomson Scientific |
(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.