n
this interview, Dr. Anthony J. Campillo, Editor-in-Chief of
Optics Letters, talks about the citation record of this
journal, particularly in the field of Photonics. When Special
Topics analyzed research published in this field over the past
decade, Optics Letters ranked at #6 by total citations, with
97 papers on Photonics garnering a total of 1,273 citations at
the time of the analysis. Currently in the ISI
Essential
Science Indicators
Web product, Optics Letters has 7,010 papers cited a total of
75,320 times to date in the field of Physics.
|
Why
do you think Optics Letters is so highly cited?
I believe that the journal’s success is largely due to its
established reputation for rapid publication and exceptionally high
technical standards. These in turn lead to an environment attracting
the best manuscripts/authors. Quality peer review, in particular, is
key to the journal’s continuing high regard within the optics
community. This aspect is enhanced by the journal’s association
with the Optical Society of America (OSA), its publisher, and gives Optics
Letters a considerable edge over journals offered by large
commercial publishers. The OSA is a 13,000-member non-profit
professional society dedicated to advancing and disseminating
knowledge in all aspects of optics. Besides organizing several major
international conferences yearly, the OSA also regularly promotes
numerous smaller topical meetings to encourage researchers around
the world, working on similar problems, to effectively network. The
journal benefits from these networks by drawing its editors, who are
all volunteers, from these specialized research communities. In
addition to myself, there are 19 topical editors and four advisory
editors from academia, government, and private enterprise, each an
expert in his/her field and highly regarded professionally. The
Topical Editors suggest referees they judge to be qualified and, in
many cases, also know personally. Because of the societal connection
and the personal contact between editors and referees, the referees
feel a professional duty to promptly respond with critical and
constructive reviews. In general, comments for each manuscript are
solicited from at least two referees, and technical content,
novelty, and need for rapid publication are evaluated. The
relatively high rejection rate, which is currently about 50%,
assures that only the highest quality manuscripts are published.
Aside from the editors, the rest of the journal’s staff consists
of full-time employees of the OSA. They coordinate routine
correspondence between editors, reviewers, and authors, copy-edit
accepted manuscripts, determine page layout and produce both the
printed and online versions of the journal, all in a highly
professional manner.
It is worth mentioning that the OSA also employs similar
peer-review and production methods in their other print journals.
Consequently, of the ISI-ranked OSA journals, all are listed in the
top 10 of optics journals. Indeed, of the top 25 cited papers in
Optoelectronics from 1991-1999, 22 were published in OSA journals
(see Thomson ISI Special Topics, August 2001; http://esi-topics.com/optoelectronics/papers/a1.html).
These include Optics Letters (8), Journal of the Optical
Society of America B (7), the Journal of the Optical Society
of America A (4), and the Journal of Lightwave Technology
(3). Optics Letters has a somewhat higher impact factor than
its sister journals, I suspect, because of its shorter
mean-time-to-publication and its convenient three-page format. The
other OSA print journals, intended as forums for full-length papers,
have a less urgent production schedule.
Have
there been specific developments in the field of Physics that may have
contributed?
Yes, there have been several. In particular, the area of
ultrafast optical phenomena has produced the "year’s
most-cited article" in Optics Letters in six of the last
10 years. Ultrafast optics encompasses methods to produce,
characterize, and utilize light pulses with durations of
femtoseconds or less. Although femtosecond lasers have been
available since the mid-1970s, the experimental arrangements needed
were quite a challenge to maintain. Day-to-day operation required
continuing realignment of many complex optical components.
Consequently, the field grew slowly despite its enormous potential
in chemistry and physics. A breakthrough occurred with the discovery
of Kerr-lens mode locking, first published in Optics Letters,
which provided a far more simple arrangement. The six highly cited
works are among those that contributed to the development of a novel
Ti:sapphire laser employing Kerr-lens modelocking. Besides producing
record-breaking short-duration pulses, the resultant light source
was inherently more stable, easier to maintain, and amenable to
commercialization. The much greater convenience of this system led
to its increasingly widespread use in science and technology and a
surge in the number of citations to this area.
Another exciting development has been the emergence of engineered
nanostructured and microstructured optical materials. Examples of
these include photonic band-gap materials, left-handed materials,
and holey fibers. Light propagating in photonic band-gap materials,
for example, behave much like an electron does in a semiconductor.
Such metamaterials have, among other properties, strongly modified
emissive behavior and are finding use in light-emitting diodes,
stealth radar/infrared structures, and ultra low-noise optical
detectors. Holey fibers are another example of a microstructured
material. These have a regular pattern of micro-capillaries running
along the length of the fiber. The effective refractive index of the
composite lies between that of air and glass and so these materials
may be configured to have properties not obtainable in the usual
all-glass optical fibers. Applications envisioned include
telecommunications, laser surgery, atom guiding, frequency
metrology, and frequency conversion. An example of the latter was an
Optics Letters’ article by Ranka et al. in 2000 in
which a holey fiber was used to efficiently convert a red ultrafast
pulse into a white-light continuum. Based on rate of recent
citations, this article was identified by Sci-Bytes as the hottest
paper in optics and acoustics published during the previous two
years (http://in-cites.com/research/2001/december_17_2001-3.html).
A strong technological driver has been recent interest in optical
fiber communication. Many issues important to the success of this
concept involve the interaction and propagation of short-duration
high-intensity pulses in fibers. So, this has generated a large body
of supporting research in nonlinear optical phenomena, optical
solitons, and the development of optical components such as
switches, filters, and amplifiers needed for this technology.
Optical fiber communication is an example of photonics, where
photons have been substituted when convenient for electrons in
high-speed microcircuits.
Finally, there has been a flurry of activity related to medical
and biological aspects of optics. Diagnostics like optical coherence
tomography, ultrafast gating, and diffusive wave optics are being
employed to extract the image of an object deeply embedded in a
highly scattering medium, such as a tumor in tissue. Another popular
topic is optical tweezers, in which a tightly focused laser beam is
used to trap and manipulate particles. Such tweezers allow fine
control over forces as small as a few hundredths of a piconewton and
have increased understanding of a wide variety of bio-motor
molecules and mechanoenzymes. Other examples include novel nonlinear
optical microscopes enabling high-resolution nondestructive chemical
analyses in vivo and optical fiber sensors to measure
blood-sugar content or to gauge the amount of radiation received
during prostate cancer treatment.
How
do you envision the state of our knowledge in this particular field 10
years from now?
Optics is one of the oldest subfields of physics, yet is still
very rich scientifically and technologically and continues to
evolve. So I see rewarding times ahead. In some instances, for
example, the continued expansion of optical diagnostics into
biomedicine and the maturation of optical fiber communication and
photonics are easily anticipated. Yet, based on past experience,
some of the most important developments will likely not have been
foreseen. Still, let me mention a few others that seem obvious.
There are a number of highly unique optical materials that have just
recently been fabricated. Two classes include nanostructured
metamaterials and Bose-Einstein condensates. There will be a greater
understanding of their optical behavior as well as practical devices
constructed to utilize them. For example, left-handed materials, or
structures displaying both a negative refractive index and magnetic
permeability, show potential in the fabrication of novel lenses to
overcome the diffraction resolution limit. This would have enormous
implications in lithography, allowing the fabrication of the next
generation of microchips and increasing the computing power of
personal computers. Finally, I would expect optics to play a
significant role in the development of quantum computers and quantum
cryptography, applications that are currently in their infancy.
What
would you like to convey to the general public about Optics Letters’s
work?
Optics is an exciting field in which to work, spanning as it does
an impressive variety of visually stimulating and intellectually
challenging phenomena. These include traditional optical instruments
like microscopes and spectrometers as well as lasers, nonlinear
optics, holography, quantum optics, photonics, cloud optics, optical
computing and processing, ultrafast phenomena, and nanooptics.
Optics also plays an important role in several sciences, including
chemistry, biology, physics, materials, meteorology, and astronomy
as well as areas of current technological importance, such as
telecommunications, displays, and lighting. Devices such as
fiber-optic perimeter sound sensors, chemical-biological agent
detectors, and optical face-recognition camera systems are currently
also having an impact on homeland defense. It is this
interdisciplinary nature, inherent elegance, and practical relevance
that attracts many to the field and, ultimately, causes optics
papers to be generously cited.
Optics Letters
Dr. Anthony J. Campillo, Editor-in-Chief
Optical Society of America, publishers
|
ESI Special Topics,
April 2003
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/photonics/interviews/opticsletters.html
|
|