|
ESI Special
Topics: October 2007
Citing URL: http://esi-topics.com/sch2007/interviews/RobertMcCarley.html |
|
 |
An ESSAY with Dr. Robert McCarley |
|
|
|
n
our September 2007 analysis of schizophrenia research over
the past decade, the work of Dr. Robert McCarley ranks at
#9, with 75 papers cited a total of 2,668 times. His
most-cited paper, "A review of MRI findings in
schizophrenia" (Shenton ME,
et al., Schizophrenia Research 49[1-2]: 1-52, 15
April 2001), ranks at #10 on our list of the top 20 papers
on the disease published in the past decade. Over the past
decade, Dr. McCarley has published over 400 papers, of which
158 original articles and review papers are classified as
Highly Cited Papers in
Essential
Science IndicatorsSM,
with a total of 4,349 citations to date. Schizophrenia is
not Dr. McCarley’s sole focus; he has also published an
impressive number of papers related to sleep research: of
the 158 papers in the top 1% in Essential Science
Indicators, 21 (with a total of 548 citations) deal with
the neurobiology of sleep. Dr. McCarley is Professor and
Director of the Neuroscience Laboratory and the Chair of the
Harvard Department of Psychiatry, as well as
the Associate Director of Mental Health, at VA Boston
Healthcare. Dr. McCarley shares some of the highlights of
his career in this field with us in the essay below. |
I was graduated from Harvard College summa cum laude and
from Harvard Medical School. Intending in college to work in
psychoanalysis, I became enthralled with neuroscience in medical
school. During and after my residency at Massachusetts Mental Health
Center, I worked on single-unit recording in the brainstem to
determine how REM sleep was generated, and I had the unusual and
heady experience of having my first paper published in Science
(McCarley RW, Hobson JA, "Cortical unit activity in desynchronized
sleep," 167[919]: 901-3, 6 February 1970).
This had implications not only for basic research but for
psychiatry, and my twin articles with Allan Hobson in the
American Journal of Psychiatry ("The neurobiological origins of
psychoanalytic dream theory," 134[11]: 1211-21, November 1977 and
"The brain as a dream state generator: an activation-synthesis
hypothesis of the dream process," 134[12]: 1335-48, December 1977 )
on the "Activation-Synthesis"
model of REM sleep control, not generated by
wish-fulfillment/disguise but by an automatic biological rhythm—and
the origins of Freud’s dream theory in early neurobiology—were
initially controversial but finally became received wisdom.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
“I was convinced brain abnormalities must be
at the root of this horribly life-distorting disorder.” |
|
|
|
|
Clinically I treated many individuals with schizophrenia, and
when a psychiatry resident, Ron Morstyn, came to me with a proposal
to do evoked-potential neurophysiological studies in schizophrenia,
I jumped at the chance since I was convinced brain abnormalities
must be at the root of this horribly life-distorting disorder. We
found a deficit in the P300 evoked potential over the left temporal
lobe, prompting a move to CT scans and then to structural MRI’s to
find the brain structural correlates. Based on the neurobiology, I
naturally hypothesized the language abnormalities must lie in the
left temporal lobe of our right-handed subjects, and was delighted
to have Marty Shenton (who is also in this Special Topics analysis)
as a post-doc trained in thought disorder measurement join in this
effort.
As MRI technology matured, Marty and I were able to document this
relationship between thought disorder and left superior temporal
gyrus (STG) volume reduction in a citation classic, "Abnormalities
of the left temporal-lobe and thought-disorder in schizophrenia - a
quantitative magnetic-resonance-imaging study" ( N.
Eng. J. Med. 327[9]: 604-612, 27 August 1992). Further work
showed that the P300 abnormalities were indeed also linked to STG
volume reduction. This work had been done in chronic patients;
collaboration with Dean Salisbury first as a post-doc and then as he
moved to McLean Hospital (as well as work from many wonderful
post-docs from Japan and Korea) showed that the STG and P300
abnormalities were present at first hospitalization for
schizophrenia and were distinct from those seen in manic and
affective psychosis at first hospitalization (Yoshio Hirayasu was
the first author on many of these papers).
Work in many other brain regions also showed a link with
structural volumetric and clinical symptom abnormalities, and this
MRI work in collaboration with Marty Shenton continued as she
established her own lab at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in 2005.
Work on N400 and other language- and semantic-related ERPs in
schizophrenia led by Dr. Margaret Niznikiewicz, VA ERP lab chief,
further pointed to the biological basis of abnormal language
processing in schizophrenia and helped specify the abnormalities (J.
Abnormal Psychology 1:85-97, 1997).
My work in neurobiology kept me informed about the increasing
evidence of dendritic plasticity, alteration by experience and by
excitotoxic phenomena, and in an article published with laboratory
members in 1991, I suggested that there was likely to be post-onset
progression of brain changes in schizophrenia, in addition to the
developmental abnormalities. Obviously this needed testing, and my
collaborators and I began a longitudinal study of
first-hospitalization subjects with schizophrenic and affective
(manic) psychosis using repeated ERPs and MRI scans. Data finally
became sufficient to publish documentation in 2003 (Kasai K, et
al. "Progressive decrease of left superior temporal gyrus gray
matter volume in first-episode schizophrenia," Am. J. Psychiat.
160[1]:156-64, January 2003; and Kasai K, et al.,
"Progressive decrease of left Heschl’s gyrus and planum temporale
gray matter volume in schizophrenia: a longitudinal MRI study of
first-episode patients," Arch. Gen. Psychiat. 60[8]: 766-75,
August 2003) that left posterior STG and its components of Heschl’s
gyrus and planum temporale showed both initially smaller volumes and
a post-onset progressive volume reduction of 8-9% over 1.5 years
after first hospitalization.
Moreover, in 2007 Dean Salisbury (first author) and I showed that
the Mismatch Negativity Evoked Potential to pitch changes shows
concomitant progression with Heschl’s gyrus volume reduction
("Progressive and interrelated functional and structural evidence of
post-onset brain reduction in schizophrenia,"
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
64[5]:521-9, May 2007). More recently Moto Nakamura (first author)
and I published data showing that overall neocortical gray matter
showed a post-onset volume reduction, most pronounced in temporal
and frontal lobes, and specific to schizophrenia vs. manic psychosis
("Neocortical gray matter volume in first-episode schizophrenia and
first-episode affective psychosis: a cross-sectional and
longitudinal MRI study,"
Biol. Psychiatry 62[7]:773-83,
1 October 2007).
The idea of post-onset progression was initially controversial,
going against the prevailing dogma of purely developmental
abnormalities, but our work and that of others has now led to much
more widespread acceptance. I and other Harvard researchers now have
the support of a major NIMH award (Boston CIDAR) to study
vulnerability to progression in schizophrenia, including its
genetics, and, with Larry Seidman, extending the scope of study to
include individuals prodromal for schizophrenia.
Another offshoot of my work in neurobiology has been in models of
abnormal circuitry in schizophrenia. Robby Greene (now at UTSW, and
then a collaborator on in vitro work in sleep), Heinz Grunze,
and I looked at an in vitro model that indicated that NMDA
synapses on inhibitory GABAergic neurons (from pyramidal projection
neurons) were much more susceptible to inhibition than those on
projection cells (pyramidal cells) by psychotomimetics ("NMDA-dependent
modulation of CA1 local circuit inhibition," J. Neurosci.
16[6]:2034-43, 15 March 1996).
This led to the hypothesis of abnormal GABA-pyramidal neuronal
interaction in schizophrenia, and to an investigation of Gamma band
(~40 Hz) oscillations, which are based on this interaction and form
the basis for communication between brain cell columns and regions.
We found steady-state (auditory click-elicited) gamma abnormalities
in schizophrenia (Kwon JS, et al., "Gamma frequency-range
abnormalities to auditory stimulation in schizophrenia," Arch.
Gen. Psychiat. 56[11]: 1001-5, November 1999), and then in a
PNAS paper, Kevin Spencer and I reported abnormalities elicited
by visual gestalt stimuli (Spencer KM, et al., "Neural
synchrony indexes disordered perception and cognition in
schizophrenia," PNAS 101[49]: 17288-93, 7 December 2004).
Work on postulated circuit abnormalities continues by Kevin and, in
post-mortem material, by Wilson Woo in the Boston CIDAR.
My interest in schizophrenia came from my empathy with those
suffering from this disorder and my frustration at my inability as a
clinical psychiatrist to treat patients completely. I believe
rational treatment will come only from better understanding of the
disorder—but this is a disorder that is multifaceted, multicausal,
and with multiple genetic influences. Progress is now being made on
many fronts of understanding due to public support of research, but
continued support by the public and continued efforts of researchers
are needed to better understand and treat this disorder.
Robert W. McCarley, M.D.
Harvard Department of Psychiatry
Harvard Medical School
and
VA Boston Healthcare
Brockton, MA, USA
|
Dr. Robert McCarley's
most-cited paper with 404 cites to date: |
|
Shenton ME, et al., "A review of MRI findings
in schizophrenia," Schizophr. Res. 49(1-2):
1-52, 15 April 2001.
Source:
Essential Science Indicators. |
|
Read an interview with lead author Dr. Martha Shenton
about this paper from the Special Topic of Schizophrenia.
|
ESI Special
Topics: October 2007
Citing URL: http://esi-topics.com/sch2007/interviews/RobertMcCarley.html
|
|
|