An ESSAY by Dr. Philip Seeman
ESI Special Topics,
November 2001
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/schizophrenia/interviews/dr-philip-seeman.html
n
this essay, Dr. Philip Seeman of the University of Toronto
discusses his work in psychosis and brain dopamine receptors.
He is among the top 30 most-cited schizophrenia researchers of
the 1990’s, with 22 papers cited a total of 924 times. His
paper, "Dopamine D4 receptors elevated in
schizophrenia" (Nature, 365[6445]: 441-5, 30
September 1993), has been cited 373 times to date. This paper
is the fifth most-cited schizophrenia research publication of
the past decade. ISI
Essential
Science Indicators
Web product
indicates that Dr. Seeman has a variety of papers published in
the fields of Neuroscience & Behavior and
Psychiatry/Psychology, as well as in the Multidisciplinary
field.
|
I was born curious. How did things work? Could I
build it? Mysteries, puzzles and adventures, especially the
cryptographic adventure in Edgar Allen Poe's "Gold Bug",
preoccupied me as a young boy in Montreal. From building model
airplanes and working with home chemistry sets, it was only a small
step into science.
But how did I become a medical researcher? My
American classmates at McGill medical school recommended a rotating
internship at Harper Hospital in Detroit. That internship made me
realize that my best efforts at curing the sick were limited. I never
seemed to cure anybody—the same patients kept coming back, their
high blood pressure still high, or their asthma still severe. A
turning point occurred one late night at the Detroit Children's
hospital. While re-starting an intravenous infusion of plasma into a
hemophiliac ten-year-old boy, I noticed his mother sitting there in
the dark. "I have two other hemophiliac children, and I'm
expecting a baby," she said. I felt defeated, because this woman
was bringing disease into the world faster than I could stamp it out.
That's when I decided to go into medical research. Perhaps I could do
something I liked, while, hopefully, the research would do some good
to patients by solving a medical problem on a long-term basis.
I then turned to a Ph.D. program at Rockefeller
University in New York, and my wife, a psychiatrist, invited me to
visit the wards at Manhattan State Hospital. The sight of two thousand
patients who had schizophrenia or psychosis was unforgettable. She
said, "Why don't you do something useful? Why don't you find the
cause of schizophrenia?"
As a first step in searching for the cause of
schizophrenia, I decided to determine how antipsychotic drugs worked.
The next step would be to see whether "the antipsychotic site of
action" was overactive in schizophrenia. For the next ten years,
therefore, I searched for an "antipsychotic receptor" in the
brain. Because it was known that nanomolar concentrations of
haloperidol alleviated hallucinations and delusions in psychotic
patients, I looked for any site in the brain which was sensitive to
this low concentration of one nanomole of haloperidol per liter of
plasma water. For this purpose, I examined the brain striatum (which
consists of the putamen and caudate nucleus), because it contained
dopamine and because it was known that haloperidol and other
antipsychotic drugs elicited a Parkinson-like or
dopamine-deficient-like syndrome of tremor and rigidity.
I finally discovered this nanomolar binding site
in 19741, and 19752,3, and named it the "neuroleptic/dopamine
receptor," later re-christened as the dopamine D2 receptor4.
All the antipsychotic drugs block this site at concentrations related
to their clinical potency5,6. This work provided the first
direct evidence that antipsychotic drugs acted on dopamine receptors,
because animal work had difficulty concluding which of the
catecholamine receptors were selectively blocked by these drugs7,8.
It then became possible to measure brain D2
receptors in patients. An excess of D2 receptors was found in
schizophrenia when using radio-spiperone but not when using
radio-raclopride9,10, possibly because the former labels
monomers of D2, while the latter labels both monomers and dimers of D211.
The "dopamine overactivity hypothesis of
psychosis" has been criticized because clozapine and quetiapine
are clinically effective antipsychotics with only 10-45% occupation of
D2 receptors, in contrast to 60-80% occupation of the D2 receptors by
all other antipsychotics12. The low occupation of D2 by
clozapine and quetiapine is explained by their rapid release from D2,
transiently occupying high levels of D2 receptors in patients but only
for the first few hours after ingestion12,13. Moreover,
recent work on imaging both D2 and serotonin-2 receptors in patients
taking antipsychotics fails to find evidence for a contribution from
the occupation of serotonin receptors in either the antipsychotic
action or the Parkinson-eliciting action.
While dopamine dysregulation probably leads to
the psychotic episode, further research needs to uncover underlying
mechanisms that predispose the brain to the dysregulation of the
dopamine system. Although the dopamine hypothesis remains the best
explanation for the origin and treatment of clinical signs and
symptoms of psychosis, the new principles, some of which are mentioned
above, are now leading to effective medications essentially free of
the old side-effects.
References:
1. Seeman, P., Wong, M., and Lee, T. "Dopamine
receptor-block and nigral fiber-impulse blockade by major
tranquilizers." Fed. Proc. 33: 246, Abstr. 243
(1974).
2. Seeman, P., Wong, M., and Tedesco, J. "Tranquilizer
receptors in rat striatum." Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 1:
405(1975).
3. Seeman, Chau-Wong, M., Tedesco, J., and
Wong, K. "Brain receptors for antipsychotic drugs and
dopamine: Direct binding assays." Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci.,
U.S.A. 72: 4376-4380 (1975).
4. Kebabian, J., and Caine, D.B. "Multiple
receptors for dopamine." Nature 277: 93-96 (1979).
5. Seeman, P., Lee, T., Chau-Wong, M., and
Wong, K. "Antipsychotic drug doses and neuroleptic/dopamine
receptors." Nature 261: 717-719 (1976).
6. Seeman, P., and Tallerico, T. "Antipsychotic
drugs which elicit little or no Parkinsonism bind more loosely than
dopamine to brain D2 receptors, yet occupy high levels of these
receptors." Mol. Psychiat. 3: 123-134 (1998).
7. Corrodi, H., Fuxe, K., and Hokfelt, T. "The
effect of neuroleptics on the activity of central catecholamine
neurones." Life Sci. 6: 767-774 (1967).
8. Andén, N.-E., Butcher, S.G., Corrodi, H.,
Fuxe, K., and Ungerstedt, U. "Receptor activity and turnover
of dopamine and noradrenaline after neuroleptics." Eur.
J. Pharmacol. 11: 303-314 (1970).
9. Wong, D.F., Pearlson, G.D., Tune, L.E.,
Young, L.T., Meltzer, C.C., Dannals, R.F., Ravert, H.T., Reith, J.,
Kuhar, M.J. & Gjedde, A. "Quantification of
neuroreceptors in the living human brain. 4. Effect of aging and
elevations of D-2-like receptors in schizophrenia and bipolar
illness." J. Cereb. Blood Flow Metab. 17: 331-342
(1997).
10. Nordström, A.-L., Farde, L., Eriksson, L.
& Halldin, C. "No elevated d-2 dopamine-receptors in
neuroleptic-naive schizophrenic-patients revealed by positron
emission tomography and [c-11] n-methylspiperone." Psychiatry
Res. Neuroirnaging 61: 67-83 (1995).
11. Zawarynski, P., Tallerico, T., Seeman, P.,
Lee, S.P., O'Dowd, B.F. & George, S.R. "Dopamine D2
receptor dimers in human and rat brain." FEBS Letts
441: 383-386 (1998).
12. Seeman, P., and Tallerico, T. "Rapid
release of antipsychotic drugs from dopamine D2 receptors: An
explanation for low receptor occupancy and early clinical relapse
upon drug withdrawal of clozapine or quetiapine." Amer.
J. Psychiat. 156: 876-884 (1999).
13. Kapur, S., Zipursky, R., Jones, C., Shammi,
C.S., Remington, G., and Seeman, P. "A PET study of
quetiapine in schizophrenia: A preliminary finding of an
antipsychotic effect with only transiently high dopamine D2 receptor
occupancy." Arch Gen. Psychiat. 57: 553-559 (2000).
Dr. Philip Seeman
University of Toronto
Pharmacology and Psychiatry Departments
Toronto, Canada
|
ESI Special Topics,
November 2001
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/schizophrenia/interviews/dr-philip-seeman.html
|
|
|