An INTERVIEW with Dr. Margo A. Brinton, Ph.D.
ESI Special Topics,
January 2003
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/westnile/interviews/MargoABrinton.html
n
a recent Special Topics analysis of West Nile virus research
published over the past decade, Dr. Margo Brinton ranked at
#7, with 10 papers cited a total of 165 times. Three of her
papers are included in the top 25 papers in this topic. Dr.
Brinton’s most-cited paper ranks at #3 on our list with 46
citations: "BHK cell proteins that bind to the 3’
stem-loop structure of the West Nile virus genome RNA," (Journal
of Virology 69[9]: 5650-8, September 1995). Dr. Brinton is
Professor of Biology at Georgia State University in Atlanta.
Below, she talks with Special Topics correspondent Gary Taubes
about her highly cited work.
|
You
have been working on West Nile virus long before it appeared in the
U.S. When did you start and why?
I started working on
West Nile virus in 1968, while I was a Ph.D. student at the University
of Pennsylvania. My dissertation work was on genetic resistance to
flaviviruses in mice. Mice with the resistant allele of this gene
survive what would normally be a lethal infection for susceptible
mice. My project was to analyze how flavivirus infections differed in
resistant and susceptible cells. The results suggested that the
resistant allele functioned intracellularly at the level of viral
genomic RNA synthesis.
And
just for clarification, which viruses constitute flaviviruses?
There are between 60 to 70 of them. They include yellow fever,
St. Louis encephalitis, dengue, Japanese encephalitis, tick-borne
encephalitis, and a lot of others you’ve probably
never heard of.
And
what was it about West Nile that made it worthy of study in 1968?
The mouse allele that bestows resistance to flaviviruses was
originally discovered in the 1920s, but it wasn’t until late in
the 1960s that it was appreciated that those viruses to which this
gene gave resistance were related and were all flaviviruses.
Although any of a number of flaviviruses could have been used for
these studies, I used West Nile virus because it was considered a
relatively safe flavivirus as compared with the others. Most people
with normal immune systems don’t develop disease after infection.
The other reason I used West Nile virus was because it grew
efficiently in mice and in cell cultures.
You’ve
been studying genetic resistance ever since. What is the ultimate goal
of this research?
The ultimate goal is to find out how the product of the
resistance allele confers resistance to flaviviruses. This is a
naturally occurring mutation in a cell protein that reduces the
replication efficiency of a particular type of virus. This suggests
that the interaction of cell proteins and viral products is
important in determining the amount of virus that is made by an
infected cell. In animals, the production of lower levels of virus
results in a slower spread of the infection and gives the host
immune response time to develop and clear the virus before it
overwhelms the host. Since techniques were not available to clone
the resistance gene until recently, early studies were aimed at
trying to identify the gene product by its presumed association with
viral components. Since the effect of the gene product seemed to be
at the level of viral RNA replication, initial studies investigated
the increased production of defective interfering viral RNAs by
resistant cells. We next tried to identify cell proteins that might
be associated with purified viral replication complexes to see if
they differed in resistant and susceptible cells. Because of the
difficulties encountered in purifying intact viral replication
complexes from cell membranes, the focus of the study was changed to
identifying cell proteins that interacted with the 3’ promoter
regions of the viral RNAs. The initial results of these studies were
published in the 1995 highly cited paper.
What
was it about your 1995 Journal of Virology paper that has made
it so highly cited?
That was the first report of the detection of cell proteins that
were interacting specifically with a flavivirus 3’ RNA. A
subsequent paper reported the identification of one of these
proteins as a cell translation factor, elongation factor 1 alpha.
However, the demonstration of an interaction doesn’t tell you how
the particular cell protein is being used by the virus during its
replication cycle. We are in the process of addressing this question
now.
Did
that protein turn out to be relevant?
Our recent data shows that the interaction between flavivirus
genomic RNA and this cell protein is definitely relevant for the
virus replication, but we do not yet understand what functions it
provides for the virus.
What’s
the biggest challenge in your research? It seems as if you’ve been
working on one question now for going on 35 years, which suggests that
it’s excruciatingly difficult.
I have actually worked on a number of different projects as well
as other viruses over the years, but have continued to study West
Nile host-virus interactions and genetic resistance to flaviviruses.
Sometimes it is necessary to wait until new techniques become
available before you can move forward with a project. In my lab, Dr.
Andrey Perelygin recently cloned the flavivirus resistance gene.
This discovery has opened the door for many new avenues of study.
Although we now know the identity of the gene, we do not yet
understand how it specifically reduces flavivirus genomic RNA levels
in infected cells.
Now
how has the arrival of West Nile in America changed your life and your
research?
Dramatically. The number of invitations to write reviews and to
give talks has definitely increased and I now get large numbers of
e-mail requests for West Nile virus information. This is also partly
due to the fact that I wrote an article on West Nile for Annual
Review of Microbiology this year. Interestingly, many people
think that I suddenly have gotten a lot of grant money because I’ve
been working on West Nile for so long. The truth is most of the
available funding for West Nile virus in the U.S. has so far gone to
support epidemiology, vaccine development, and setting up health
departments for surveillance and testing. Very little has yet
trickled down to basic research, but I think that in the next year
or two that will probably begin to change.
As for me personally, the first thing that happened when West
Nile virus arrived in Georgia was that I got called at six in the
morning by a news radio station. They wanted to know what kind of
mosquito spray people should be using.
With
the prospect of more funding, do you have experiments you’re already
contemplating?
Oh yes, there are many new areas for research on West Nile virus
and flavivirus genetic resistance that we are perusing. We hope that
our studies will eventually lead us to an understanding of the
connection between the resistance gene product and viral RNA
transcription. We are also analyzing mechanisms used by West Nile
virus for regulating transcription and translation.
Were
you surprised when you heard that West Nile had made it to the U.S.?
Well, I was surprised, but not greatly. West Nile virus was first
isolated in the 1930s in Africa where it has been endemic for a very
long time. Infected birds have periodically carried it across the
Mediterranean to Southern Europe and Turkey where local transmission
occurred for a single season. So the idea that this virus could
initiate a local transmission cycle after being brought to a new
geographic region was not surprising. Although it will never be
known for sure, it is possible that West Nile virus was brought to
the United States on a plane in an infected mosquito or bird. What
was surprising was that the virus successfully over-wintered in the
United States in 1999. Once the virus had survived that first
winter, we all knew it would spread across the United States and
into Canada as well as Central and South America because there are
no natural barriers.
Where
do you see this research going in the next five to ten years?
I really think that understanding the intracellular interactions
between a virus and its host cells at the molecular level will help
in the development of effective new therapies for flavivirus
infections.
Margo A. Brinton, Ph.D.
Department of Biology
Georgia State University
Atlanta, GA, USA
|
ESI Special Topics,
January 2003
Citing URL - http://www.esi-topics.com/westnile/interviews/MargoABrinton.html
|
|
|